Score: 10

"yep"

submission: ** \ Inhuman Way / **

date: July 28, 2008

I didn't hear it before you remixed it, but this is the best I've heard from you. Everything fits very well. The effects are great and the transitions are all done well. Great melodies, parts reminded me of Trans Siberian Orchestra. Really really great. I don't think I have any criticism of it at all.

Score: 9

"ahhh...."

submission: °>Walking<°in D Minor Harmonic

date: July 28, 2008

the simpleness of a walking scale....done very well with nice melody mixed into it. The only criticism I can even begin to think of for this one is that the ending tails off a little to quickly I think....well, at least let the cymbals ring nice and loud and fade out, the last one sounded cut off.

Score: 9

"another one"

submission: ** \The Dark Side of Major/ **

date: July 28, 2008

one of your best I think....I agree with some of the others that it ends too quickly. It sounds like it's really going somewhere and then just stops. And I love major/minor clashes....I think it's just awesomeness listening to dischord resolve....doing it right gives me chills, especially when I'm doing it myself.

Score: 9

"wow"

submission: Mad World - Rock

date: July 28, 2008

very nice....I saw this and was drawn to it....curious. I didn't think it would sound quite that good as a rock song. Still haven't found one to quite match the Gary Jules version, and I think some of the violin behind the strings could've been done without as I thought it was a bit distracting being very quiet so that you have to strain a bit to hear, and miss out on more of the song.

Score: 10

"I don't like you much right now"

submission: Starwars - The Imperial March

date: July 28, 2008

I don't like you much right now....I've heard someone playing a metal version of the Imperial March before and if I can't think of who it was I'll probably bang my head into several blunt objects. Seriously great though, one of the best renditions of this I've ever heard. It bugs me to hear the piano a little behind the beat. I don't know if that's what you wanted it to be like, but I really prefer the standards the drums either being on time or right behind the beat, which is extremely common in a lot of music. But not the piano, it just grates on my nerves a little bit. Still great though.

Score: 9

"cool"

submission: Trigun : Intro Theme !

date: July 28, 2008

think I prefer the original a bit, maybe because it usually comes right before the show :) I like it though and the ending is a great touch.

Score: 9

"very nice"

submission: **\ The Sleep Pt II /**

date: July 28, 2008

Liked it a lot. I give a 9 instead of a 10 because I think the switch to the keyboard section is a little abrupt....still works alright though. Also not sure about the jazz beat behind the keyboard at the beginning of that section, I think a different beat might work a little better there. I really like it a lot though, one of the better things I've heard on here definitely.

Score: 7

"well"

submission: A Wounded Picture of the End

date: July 28, 2008

couple of things that bothered me....first the horribly fake instrument sounds(especially saxophone, but I may be biased as a saxophone player). Also, I think there may be a bit too much going on in a couple places in the song, but that could just be my taste. Maybe having the male-female vocal duet was it. I'd break up the parts a bit, and have them sing separately at some points and then together, and maybe not so much unison. Overall I liked it a lot, it did somewhat remind me of Lacuna Coil, with a lot of promise.

Score: 6

"like it"

submission: The Night She Died

date: June 12, 2008

would actually be very good with better vocals I think

Score: 8

"good"

submission: Falling Farther (Trance Remix)

date: March 1, 2008

I agree that the abrupt stop works well for that point in the song. abrupt stops aren't really much of my style though. overall I liked it though.